Home Page

President’s Forum No. 151 | Authors Conclude Medicare Advantage Should be Abolished

NRLN President’s Forum 
By Bill Kadereit

An analysis in the JAMA (Journal of the American Medical Association) Internal Medicine on June 10 concluded: “We think the time has come to declare MA [Medicare Advantage] a failed experiment and abolish it. That would allow redeploying the $88 billion taxpayers will overpay MA this year to upgrade benefits for all Medicare beneficiaries.”

The conclusion was based on the high cost of MA compared to traditional Medicare. For example:

Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC), the nonpartisan agency reporting to Congress, recently estimated that MA overpayments added $82 billion to taxpayers’ costs for Medicare in 2023 and $612 billion between 2007 and 2024. Two insurer strategies drive MA overpayments: diagnosis upcoding and avoiding enrollees who are ill and do not contribute to profits.

Although MA insurers must accept all applicants in counties where they offer a plan, they are also free to withdraw from counties where they are accumulating unprofitable enrollees.

Only 2% of Fee-for-Service (FFS) Medicare expenditures go for overhead. But MA insurers incur extra expenses for television advertisements, health care network management, benefit design, executive salaries, health care utilization review, prior authorization, and shareholder profits, driving their overhead up to 14%. 

This is according to a report from Milliman, an international actuarial and consulting firm, on MA financial results for 2022. Milliman estimates applied to subsequent years’ payments, MA overhead for 2007 to 2024 totals $592 billion—equivalent to 97% of taxpayers’ $612 billion overpayments to them during that period.

The authors closed their analysis stating, “A smarter, thriftier way to expand benefits and lower out-of-pocket costs is possible for all Medicare beneficiaries, but first, we must eliminate MA and double down on traditional Medicare, covering all enrollees in an expanded and improved Medicare program. That would be a good deal for patients and taxpayers.”

 

READ THE ARTICLE…

Submit your Email Address to receive Future Issues of the President's Forum

If you did not receive an email with the NRLN President’s Forum message or an Action Alert posted on this home page, possibly you mistakenly “unsubscribed” on one of our emails or you have a new email address. You will no longer hear from us unless you “re-subscribe”. ​

HOW YOU CAN HELP:

  • SUBSCRIBE to receive periodic emails
  • ACT on NRLN Action Alerts
  • CONTRIBUTE to NRLN’s lobby effort
  • Make a tax-deductible DONATION to our American Retirees Education Foundation (AREF) research

THE PRESIDENT'S LETTERS TO WASHINGTON ON BEHALF OF RETIREES

NRLN Provides New “Report Card” Feature on Members of Congress.  Do your Senators or Representative support bills that help retirees?

Do You Know Whether Your Medicare Advantage Plan Will Continue in 2025?

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email
Print

Undoubtedly there are thousands of NRLN members with Medicare Advantage (MA) plans. Four MA insurance companies who provide MA plans have announced they will drop over 1 million enrollees across the nation in 2025.

Humana has told investors that the company expects to lose about 560,000, about 10% of its MA enrollees next year after it exits 13 unprofitable markets and trims its plan options. CVS Health Aetna will force 420,000 members to find other coverage. Centene – Wellcare announced in August it will be ending plans which will impact roughly 37,000 enrollees. Up to 5,395 Cigna beneficiaries will have to find new plans. UnitedHealthcare has not announced whether it will drop MA enrollees.

There have been news reports that MA insurers will be adding or raising premiums and increasing the out-of-pocket amounts due to higher expenses and lower profits as MA plan enrollees get older and have more healthcare costs. If your plan is discontinued, it is an opportunity to give thought to whether you want to continue in an MA plan (Part C) or enroll in original Medicare (Parts A and B) and a Medigap plan.

If you have not heard from your MA insurer about the status of your plan for next year, you should immediately contact your MA plan provider or your insurance agent to learn whether your plan will be continued. 

If your plan is going to end on December 31, 2024, you should be sure to obtain a letter or email from your MA plan provider that states, as federal law requires, that you have a Guaranteed Issue Right (GIR) to get another MA plan or go into Original Medicare. 

With a GIR you can acquire an MA plan or enroll in an Original Medicare, and if you choose, buy a supplement policy (Medigap) to cover the 20% that Medicare does not pay. The GIR provides you 63 days after your current MA Plan coverage ends to obtain other healthcare coverage. The upcoming Medicare Open Enrollment period October 15 – December 7 will be available to enroll in a new plan. 

During the 63-day window, you cannot be denied for an MA plan or Original Medicare with a Medigap plan due to a pre-existing medical condition or face underwriting due to your medical history. 

If your MA plan ends and you do not take action to acquire a different MA plan or enroll in Original Medicare you will be automatically enrolled in Original Medicare, but without a Medigap plan. Your MA plan that may be ending could have included Medicare Part D for prescription drugs. If so, it would be wise to shop for and purchase a Medicare Part D plan or an MA plan that includes Part D coverage. 

Keep any letters, notices, or emails from your MA plan stating that your plan will be discontinued. You may need the information to prove your coverage ended to gain a GIR.

 

The NRLN website at www.nrln.org has video to assist anyone who wants to shop for a Medigap plan on www.medicare.gov. Another video will be created and posted in early October on how to search for Medicare Advantage plans on www.medicare.gov

The NRLN wants to help you get the healthcare coverage that is right for you at the best price. Ask your friends to sign up at https://nrln.org/2021/01/email-sign-up/ to receive NRLN emails. We will keep you informed on this MA issue and other issues important to retirees. 

Bill Kadereit, President
National Retiree Legislative Network 

Medicare Advantage: Coverage Options, Benefits, Enrollment, and Healthcare Impact

GET READY for Medicare Open Enrollment

Start Getting Ready for Annual Medicare Enrollment

The NRLN will be posting a series of short videos and brief articles to help our members prepare for the annual Medicare enrollment October 15 – December 7, 2024. 

The first video is below. Click on the play icon to learn about three steps you can start taking now to be better prepared for the enrollment period.

  1. Make a list of your healthcare costs.
  2. Note changes to your health.
  3. Make a pros and cons list of traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans.

Send an email to contact@nrln.org to tell us what other information would be useful to you to prepare for enrollment and during enrollment.

Welcome to the latest NRLN Chapter Highlights! Across the country, our chapters are actively advocating for retirees’ rights and well-being. This edition showcases our members’ recent efforts, from engaging policymakers to hosting educational events. Discover how our community is making a difference for retirees nationwide!

NRLN CHAPTERS
NRLN Grassroots Network

NRLN Grassroots Network is the name for having support from NRLN members to respond to Action Alerts plus having Region, State and Congressional District leaders to support the NRLN’s Washington, D.C. lobbying efforts.

NRLN - Your Source for Medicare Enrollment 2025

MEDICARE AND YOU HANDBOOK 2025

IMPORTANT

In the News

The articles and opinion pieces below are for information and are not necessarily a reflection of the NRLN’s position on issues.

The NRLN is nonpartisan and its positions on retirement issues are presented in its Legislative Agenda and white papers that can be accessed from under the Legislative Agenda tab on the website main menu.

2025 Medicare Part D Drug Plan Premiums: Under Control But In Flux Forbes – Oct. 2, 2024

Medicare Advantage giant Humana reels after ratings cut The Washington Post – Oct. 2, 2024 

Medicare Downgrades Humana Plan Over Quality. Time to Shop Around?Barron’s – Oct. 2, 2024

US Medicare issues updated rules for second round of drug negotiations Reuters – Oct. 2, 2024 

Don’t Ignore the Letter You Just Got From Your Medicare Part D Provider Investopedia – Oct. 2, 2024

Health insurers unveil Medicare Advantage plans for 2025 Reuters – Oct. 1, 2024

For 2025, Insurers Pull Back Slightly On Medicare Advantage Footprints Forbes – Oct. 1, 2024

UnitedHealthcare 2025 Medicare Advantage Plans Deliver Choice, Stability Press Release – Oct. 1, 2024

Aetna Updates MA and Drug Programs for Medicare in 2025 Managed Healthcare – Oct. 1. 2024

With Medicare’s annual enrollment period 2 weeks away, here’s what major payers will have on offer Fierce Healthcare – Oct. 1, 2024

Are Online Discount Websites Helping Medicare Beneficiaries? The Commonwealth Fund – Oct. 1, 2024

3 key changes will help poor qualify for more money through a Social Security program USA TODAY – Oct. 1, 2024

Medicare Patients To Save Up to $3,800 Per Day With New Rebate Newsweek – Sept. 30, 2024

Medicare Advantage Penetration Expected To Continue In 2025 Home Health Care – Sept. 30, 2024

Some Gen Xers Are Counting On Social Security—But Few Millennials Are Investopedia – Sept. 30, 2024

Medicare Advantage season arrives with a dose of confusion and political implications Health News Florida – Sept. 30, 2024

Historic numbers of Americans live by themselves as they age KFF Health News – Sept. 30, 2024

As Election Looms, Medicare Premiums Will ‘Remain Stable’ For 2025 Forbes – Sept. 27, 2024

Biden-Harris admin probe urged over Medicare premium offset plan before election Fox News – Sept. 27, 2024

What Happens If My Medicare Advantage Plan Has Been Canceled? Retirement Daily on the Street – Sept. 26, 2024

As Medicare Open Enrollment Approaches, Seniors Don’t Study Options Forbes – Sept. 26, 2024

Effort to force vote on Social Security bill stirs unrest in House GOP The Hill Newspaper – Sept. 26, 2024

New Bill Increases Social Security Death Benefit  Think Advisor – Sept. 26, 2024

Your Continued Help Is Needed: Please make your annual contribution of $35, $50, $75 or more. Any amount you contribute will be appreciated. Make your check or money order payable to NRLN, Inc. and mail it  to the NRLN at 601 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W., Suite 900 | South Building, Washington, DC 20004-2601. Or, make your contribution with your credit card or PayPal at by
CLICKING THE BUTTON BELOW. 

STAY CONNECTED

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More...

Verified by MonsterInsights